Understanding Gestational Surrogacy vs Traditional Surrogacy

Surrogacy is a unique and life-changing experience for surrogates, but understanding the types of surrogacy is essential. Defining the difference between gestational surrogacy vs traditional surrogacy in biological terms is straightforward. However, being aware of the legal and emotional differences between the two methods can be more complicated. As one of the most trusted and experienced surrogacy resources nationwide and worldwide, we're passionate about educating and empowering surrogates.

History of Surrogacy

Before in vitro fertilization (IVF) became more common, individuals or couples relied exclusively on traditional surrogacy, which involves the surrogate using her own eggs to create the embryo. Modern traditional surrogacy began in the U.S. in 1976 when attorney Noel Keane negotiated and drafted the nation's first formal contract between a surrogate and a married couple. In the late 1980s, the groundbreaking " changed the future of surrogacy when the New Jersey Supreme Court invalidated a surrogacy contract. Even though the couple who signed the contract was awarded custody, the case shined a spotlight on the pitfalls of traditional surrogacy.

At the same time, IVF was staking its place as an alternative to traditional surrogacy. In gestational surrogacy, the IVF process is used to create an embryo using the eggs from a donor or intended mother and the sperm from an intended father. The embryo is then implanted in the surrogate, who has no genetic connection to the baby.

As IVF techniques evolved, traditional surrogacy became less popular. Some states even passed laws establishing restrictions or outlawing them altogether. Ultimately, the rise of IVF, coupled with the attention surrounding the Baby M case, further highlighted the legal and emotional risks of traditional surrogacy. This explains why gestational surrogacies are the preferred choice for most modern surrogacy arrangements.

Traditional Surrogacy vs Gestational Surrogacy: Key Differences

If you're considering becoming a surrogate, you can empower yourself by understanding your surrogacy options.

Traditional Surrogacy

Although traditional surrogacy is no longer as commonplace as gestational surrogacy, some intended parents may be looking for a traditional surrogate. This practice features the following:

·         Surrogate uses her own eggs to create the embryos

·         Surrogate shares DNA with the baby and has a biological connection to the child

·         Parentage presents more legal complexity and less security

·         The less practiced type of surrogacy today

As previously mentioned, some states may restrict or prohibit this type of surrogacy, so it's important to know whether a traditional surrogacy arrangement is valid in your state.

Gestational Surrogacy

Most surrogacy agencies work only with gestational surrogacy arrangements. Gestational surrogacy involves the following features:

·         Surrogate does NOT use her own eggs to create the embryos

·         Surrogate does NOT share DNA with the baby and has NO biological connection to the child

·         Parentage presents less legal complexity and more security

·         The more widely practiced type of surrogacy today

As your surrogacy guides and advocates, we're always available to answer your questions and help you navigate your path.

Benefits of Gestational Surrogacy

Both surrogates and intended parents enjoy greater peace of mind using gestational surrogacy, especially when working through a top resource such as Surrogacy.com. Without the legal or emotional complications associated with having a genetic link to the baby you're carrying, you can fully experience the joy of pregnancy and childbirth as a surrogate. In essence, gestational surrogacy offers a clear-cut path to helping others build forever families in a way that's safe and fulfilling for all involved.

Comparing Traditional and Gestational Surrogacy Compensation

It's difficult to compare compensation for the two types of surrogacy directly. Surrogacy pay typically varies depending on factors such as location, whether you have previously been a surrogate, and whether you have health insurance. It's important to note that surrogates are also compensated for other benefits in addition to their base pay. As a gestational surrogate, you will never be responsible for any medical out-of-pocket costs associated with your pregnancy or delivery. The intended parents will handle these costs.

Why Choose Surrogacy.com as Your Gestational Surrogate Guide

When choosing to become a gestational surrogate, it's vital to consult with experienced surrogacy professionals who can guide you through the decision-making process and ensure you are fully protected and informed. Our team connects you with an extensive support system and network that includes caring social workers, experienced legal staff well-versed in reproductive and state-by-state surrogacy laws, and knowledgeable financial experts.

Your support team also includes a true surrogacy sisterhood of women who have been in your shoes. Some have even gone through the gestational surrogacy process as many as three times! They're available to help you navigate the application process and answer virtually any questions you may have. Learn more about surrogate requirements,  and when you're ready for the next step, use our online form to get in touch.